Technically impressive, emotionally engaging and visually compelling — but beneath its anti-colonial spirit lies a troubling layer of Hindutva-driven communal framing.
Ranabaali offers a compelling cinematic experience. It blends folklore with historical events, recreates the brutality of British colonial rule and delivers an emotionally charged fight against imperial oppression. Technically, the film is good. Its ending is powerful, and its central idea of resistance against British exploitation deserves appreciation.
But I walked away with mixed feelings.
The problem is not its criticism of British colonialism. That criticism is necessary. The problem is how the film appears to construct its villains, selectively attach religious identities to immoral behaviour, and reshape a shared history of suffering into a narrow religious narrative.
The British were brutal. But why introduce communal stereotypes?
The Great Madras Famine of 1876–78 was a devastating human catastrophe. British colonial policies, revenue priorities, inadequate relief and market decisions contributed to the suffering. India's resources and wealth were extracted for an overseas empire while millions endured unimaginable hardship.
The scenes showing British cruelty, including the treatment of starving children, are disturbing. They remind us of the human cost of colonial power.
But why does the film repeatedly bring Muslim characters and Nawab-associated settings into scenes of exploitation?
A starving father seeking grain is confronted by a man who demands his daughter in exchange. The association of a Muslim-coded character with sexual exploitation, greed and moral corruption is not an incidental cinematic detail. It creates a particular impression.
The film also invokes a Nawab's transfer of territory to the British. Yet the historical relationship between the Nizam of Hyderabad and the East India Company was far more complicated than a simplistic portrayal of a ruler handing over land. Political treaties, military arrangements and colonial expansion were involved.
Why does the film need to repeatedly place Muslim identity alongside exploitation when the principal historical system responsible for the famine was British colonial rule?
One can condemn the actions of individual Muslim rulers and characters without turning Muslim identity into a recurring symbol of moral failure.
India's freedom struggle was never the property of one religion
India was not a unified Hindu kingdom waiting to be liberated from Muslim rulers. It was a politically diverse subcontinent of competing kingdoms, regional powers, cultures and communities.
Hindu kings fought other Hindu kings. Muslim rulers fought other Muslim rulers. Hindu and Muslim rulers formed alliances, fought wars and pursued their own political interests. Some Indian rulers and local elites collaborated with the British; others resisted them.
The freedom struggle that eventually challenged British rule was equally diverse. Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs, Christians, atheists, tribal communities, peasants, workers and revolutionaries contributed to it.
Ashfaqulla Khan, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, Bhagat Singh, Udham Singh and countless others belonged to different backgrounds but shared a struggle against colonial domination.
The RSS was founded in 1925, but it did not participate as an organisation in the mass Quit India Movement of 1942. Individual members' histories may differ, but that organisational record should not be rewritten.
So why should a fictional Hindu warrior become the central representation of a freedom struggle that was actually built by people from across India's religious and social landscape?
A fictional hero is perfectly legitimate. But presenting a shared history as an exclusively Hindu civilisational victory is a different matter.
Women: mothers, victims and instruments of male honour
Another scene that troubled me was Ranabaali's mother offering her own body to save the unborn child, asking for her belly to be cut open.
It is undeniably emotional. A mother's willingness to sacrifice herself for her child can move any audience.
But there is another question: why is a woman's worth so often represented through motherhood, sacrifice and the preservation of a male family lineage?
The emphasis on the son's marriage and the continuation of his family line reinforces a deeply patriarchal idea. Women are celebrated for what they give birth to, what they sacrifice and what they preserve — rather than being represented as individuals with their own ambitions, agency and identities.
Emotional storytelling should not prevent us from questioning the social values embedded in it.
The larger problem: Hindutva's selective history
This is where my discomfort becomes political.
There is a recurring pattern in sections of contemporary historical cinema: Muslim rulers and characters are repeatedly framed as invaders, sexual predators, cruel rulers or enemies, while Hindu identity is positioned as the natural representative of Indian civilisation.
This is not an argument against portraying historical atrocities committed by Muslim rulers. Those atrocities must be discussed honestly.
But history must apply the same standards to everyone.
Why are Hindu rulers who fought other Hindu rulers, collaborated with colonial powers or oppressed their own populations not given equivalent attention? Why are the roles of Indian landlords, intermediaries and local elites in colonial administration often less prominent than the religious identity of a fictional villain?
The issue is not that a Hindu character is portrayed as a hero. The issue is when Hindu heroism becomes a vehicle for communal historical revisionism.
And we should distinguish Hinduism, a diverse religious and philosophical tradition, from Hindutva, a modern political ideology. Criticising the latter is not an attack on Hindus.
The hypocrisy of selective empathy
There is another contradiction I find difficult to ignore.
Some right-wing supporters passionately celebrate films depicting British cruelty against Indian children, women and ordinary people. They rightly become emotional about colonial atrocities. They speak about national pride, historical injustice and the suffering of our ancestors.
But where does that empathy go when Palestinian children are killed, displaced, starved or deprived of basic necessities? Where is the same moral outrage when Palestinian mothers lose their children, families are forced from their homes and civilians endure the consequences of Israeli military actions and restrictions?
This is not about equating every historical event or ignoring the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It is about applying the same human standards.
If a starving Indian child deserves our compassion, a starving Palestinian child deserves it too.
If colonial exploitation is wrong, the dispossession and oppression of Palestinians deserve to be challenged.
Human suffering cannot become acceptable or invisible because the victims are Muslim.
The same selective empathy appears in the treatment of history. Some people demand that every atrocity committed by a Muslim ruler be remembered across generations, yet become uncomfortable when colonial exploitation, Hindu elite collaboration or contemporary anti-Muslim discrimination is discussed.
That is not historical integrity. It is selective outrage.
My verdict
I appreciate Ranabaali for its technical execution, its cinematic ambition, its emotional moments and its resistance narrative against British colonialism. The ending is particularly effective.
But its communal framing, its treatment of Muslim identity and its patriarchal representation of women undermine what could have been a much more powerful historical story.
The real history of India is far richer than a contest between religious communities. It is a history of shared struggles, competing political interests, cultural exchange, resistance, exploitation and human suffering.
Anti-colonial cinema should challenge imperialism, not reproduce another form of prejudice.
We do not need to manufacture Muslim villains to make British colonial atrocities believable. We do not need to reduce women to symbols of sacrifice to make a story emotional. And we certainly do not need to turn India's diverse freedom struggle into the achievement of one religious identity.
I wanted to celebrate a film about resistance. I appreciated its cinematic strengths. But I cannot ignore the communal and ideological baggage that accompanies it.
History deserves honesty. Humanity deserves consistency. And cinema deserves better than selective nationalism.

Comments
Post a Comment